Hundreds of doctors in bellwether state disciplined for embarrassing—albeit not indecent—slip-ups
If California is a microcosm of the USA, other states should be concerned about some behind-the-scenes failings of their respective physician workforces.
That’s because a new study by the American Board of Internal Medicine (ABIM) shows more than half the Golden State’s internists, 52.3%, were disciplined for—sorry, enthusiasts of spicy scandals—gaps in their medical knowledge.
The study looks at a 12-year stretch ending in 2022 and is current in the Journal of Continuing Education in the Health Professions.
For the research, ABIM senior researcher Lauren Duhigg, MPH, and colleagues homed in on California because it leads all states in physician headcount and because its medical licensing board releases detailed descriptions of disciplinary actions.
Duhigg and co-researchers scrutinized all disciplinary descriptions of California internists who received correctional communications from 2011 through 2022.
They found 558 such actions were taken.
Of these, 52.3% were related to a medical knowledge deficit.
The rest were either unrelated to medical knowledge (43.7%) or classified as “ambiguous” (3.9%).
Duhigg and colleagues further found that physicians who got scolded for gaps in medical knowledge were less likely to have passed their initial certification exam on first attempt.
Examples of medical knowledge deficits included things like prescribing inappropriate medications, incorrectly interpreting imaging studies and ordering an unnecessary high-risk procedure that could jeopardize a patient’s health.
Don’t assume hanky-panky
In a news release, Duhigg notes the human impulse to associate the term “disciplinary actions” with unprofessional or even scandalous behaviors on the part of the disciplined.
“Our findings suggest medical knowledge deficits may play a larger role in physician disciplinary actions than many people realize, and these gaps have the potential to directly impact patient care,” Duhigg says.
To this ABIM senior VP Lorna Lynn, MD, adds:
“Medicine changes continuously, and keeping pace with new evidence and standards of care is essential to patient safety. Doctors can continue learning throughout their careers, and the association between exam performance and knowledge-related disciplinary actions points to the potential for assessment to identify and address gaps before they may place patients at risk.”
MOC tests prove predictive
ABIM points out the present study’s findings accord with prior research showing a link between poor performance on Maintenance of Certification (MOC) exams and physician disciplinary actions.
“Physicians who did not pass the MOC exam within 10 years of becoming board certified, including those who did not take it, had more than twice the rate of state medical board disciplinary actions as those who passed,” ABIM reports. “Higher exam scores were also linked to lower rates of disciplinary action.”
The study is posted here (behind paywall), the ABIM news item here.
