Patients, visitors commit most assaults of ED nurses—but coworkers involved in 1 of 5 incidents
Workplace violence is common in emergency departments, and nurses bear much if not most of the brunt. A new study shows the primary perpetrators are patients and visitors, although a considerable number of fights are picked by colleagues.
The researchers found overtime tends to raise ED nurses’ risk of encountering hostile actors, as does working the day shift and working in an ED connected to a hospital rather than a freestanding emergency operation.
Publishing their findings Nov. 13 in JAMA Network Open, Lindsay Thompson Munn, PhD, RN, and colleagues at Wake Forest University remark that their findings support workplace-violence prevention approaches that “extend beyond training and incident response alone to consider staffing practices, including overtime, and emphasize tailoring prevention strategies to ED setting and workflow context.”
For the study, the team analyzed responses from nurse surveys as well as data from EMR and administrative records. The study materials were collected from 11 EDs in the Southeast.
Thompson Munn and co-authors found that, among 337 ED nurses, some 296 (87.8%) reported workplace violence in the prior month.
Patients or visitors were involved in 98.6% of these incidents (n = 292 of 296), while coworkers had a hand in 20.3% (60 of 296).
Further, in adjusted mixed-effects models (n = 299), overtime was associated with higher odds of workplace violence (odds ratio, 3.21), while night shift (odds ratio, 0.28) and employment in a freestanding ED (odds ratio, 0.25) were associated with lower odds.
Thompson Munn and co-authors point out that emergency nurses experience some of the highest rates of workplace violence among all healthcare workers.
They cite prior research showing:
- Exposure to workplace violence is associated with burnout, depression, anxiety, posttraumatic stress symptoms and workplace turnover.
- Workplace violence may adversely affect patient safety by disrupting teamwork, communication and safety culture.
- Workplace violence results in substantial financial and operational costs for health systems. Indeed, the American Hospital Association estimates that workplace violence costs US hospitals more than $18 billion annually.
“Workplace violence arises from multiple levels within healthcare work systems, including individual clinicians, team-level dynamics and organizational conditions, yet prior research has predominantly examined workplace violence using single-factor approaches, limiting understanding of how system-level conditions shape risk,” Thomspon Munn and colleagues write.
Accordingly, the present study examines the frequency and characteristics of workplace violence among ED nurses while also unpacking important associations between multilevel system characteristics and workplace violence in the ED.
Full study here.
