Research illuminates US population’s lifetime experience of healthcare coverage, lack thereof
Before enrolling in Medicare during their senior years, many American adults fluctuate between having and not having health insurance. A new study shows insurers collectively close coverage gaps faster now than in eras past.
It also hints at how the population’s insurance status might be optimized over the lifetimes of existing generations.
The researchers found the industry circa mid-2020s is particularly responsive for low-income individuals—but even for them, periods of complete lack of coverage are a steady threat.
The study was conducted at Vanderbilt University and is current in JAMA Health Forum.
In introducing their findings, Jinyi Zhu, PhD, MPH, and colleagues note the U.S. uninsured rate dipped to its lowest-ever point in 2023. However, like all point-in-time snapshots, this data point sheds little light on Americans’ ups and downs with coverage over their lifetimes.
They launched the present study because, in their words, “understanding whether declines in uninsured rates were driven by fewer coverage losses, shorter uninsured periods or both is important as Medicaid and Marketplace eligibility rules change.”
Three representative eras
For the analysis, Zhu and co-researchers calibrated a health insurance simulation model. This let them compare synthetic birth cohorts that experienced three different eras of coverage dynamics: 2009 to 2010 (ie, pre-Affordable Care Act); 2018 to 2019 (ie, post-ACA and pre-COVID-19); and 2022 to 2023 (when COVID-19 era coverage protection policies were in effect).
The team also looked at lifetime years uninsured in order to “isolate the unique contributions” of entry rates, exit rates and shifting mortality dynamics on total expected time uninsured in each of these eras.
Zhu et al.’s key findings included:
- Expected lifetime years uninsured in the noninstitutionalized population declined from 10.98 years in 2009-2010 to 6.76 years in 2018-2019—a change of −4.73 years.
- Among people below 200% of the federal poverty level, the decline was from 19.85 years in 2009-2010 to 11.68 years in 2018-2019—a change of −8.18 years.
- Both declines were offset mainly by gains in public coverage, the researchers report. They show that mean uninsured period duration increased in the noninstitutionalized population (3.42 to 3.84 years) but fell in the low-income subcohort (4.56 to 3.94 years).
- Decomposition analysis attributed the overall decline in uninsured years to slower coverage losses; among the low-income group, the decline was attributed to fewer coverage losses and faster reentry into coverage once uninsured.
Average is between 1 and 2 uncovered periods
In their discussion section, Zhu and co-authors state their findings reveal a “fundamental rewiring” of the architecture behind U.S. health insurance between 2009 and 2023.
“On net, expected lifetime years uninsured fell by nearly five years,” they underscore. “Among the low-income cohort, reductions in coverage losses were also met with faster exit rates from uninsured periods, resulting in a reduction in the mean time spent uninsured.”
The researchers emphasize that U.S. residents continue having to navigate a patchwork of coverage options throughout their pre-Medicare years, which often leads to gaps in coverage and corresponding difficulties accessing and affording care.
“Even with the ACA’s full expansions in place in most states—as well as COVID-19-era policies that increased the affordability of insurance and the ability to retain coverage nationwide—the average person with low income in the U.S. will experience roughly three uninsured periods over their lifetimes,” Zhu and colleagues write.
Across all incomes, they add, the average U.S. resident will experience between one or two periods without coverage.
“Coverage loss is a vulnerability that the system now resolves faster than in previous eras but does not fundamentally prevent,” they point out.
Turbulence ahead
Zhu et al. believe their findings are important because they reinforce prior modeling showing “the more stringent, time-consuming and frequent eligibility reviews slated to begin in 2027 will add more turbulence to the experience of public and private health insurance in the U.S.”
More:
Upcoming policy changes are likely to both increase coverage loss rates and increase the amount of time people must wait before regaining coverage. The net result is likely to be a coverage landscape with more churn than has been observed in the U.S. in well over a decade.
The team suggests stakeholders and policymakers draw from the present research to anticipate how upcoming changes may affect the experience of coverage vs. lack thereof “not just at a point in time but over U.S. residents’ lifetimes.”
Full study here.
