CMS delays enforcement of Medicaid work requirements following pressure from states
After legal challenges and a letter from state governments urging a delay of the enforcement of Medicaid work requirements, the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) has decided to put a “transition period” in place to ease the administrative burden of enforcement.
Announced on Friday, CMS said the grace period, which delays enforcement of work requirements until July 1, will be optional. While the federal requirement that Medicaid beneficiaries work 80 hours a month, attend school or perform community volunteer work in order to keep their coverage remains the law of the land starting in the new year, until July CMS has agreed to “hold harmless” compliance.
The agency said the delay will give states time to “improve and refine their systems and processes before enforcement begins,” while offering Medicaid departments six months to “identify and address workforce training needs” so they are better prepared to develop and submit reports to CMS that show the work status of beneficiaries.
In Oct., five states penned a letter to the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. asking for a “realistic timeframe” for enforcing the work requirements and developing reports to CMS, citing the agency’s delay in announcing a final rule implementing the requirements, something they did over the summer.
Reporting, states argued in the letter as well as in a federal lawsuit, created numerous problems for Medicaid regulators, who are worried many Americans will lose their coverage simply because of a clerical error, or because they switch jobs frequently in a gig economy, something the systems put in place to track employment history will need to address.
“These are not minor or technical adjustments. They fundamentally change the processes and system logic underlying states’ implementation plans,” the letter reads. “With less than 100 days remaining before January 1, states cannot reasonably rebuild, test, and validate these systems while ensuring accurate notices, properly trained workers, and reliable, lawful coverage determinations.”
In making its announcement, CMS said it has been working with state governments to make the process easier, and it believes the delay will ultimately strengthen the work requirements long-term.
“States have made real progress, and they’ve been clear with us about what it takes to get this right for beneficiaries—at scale and for the long term,” Deputy Administrator and Director of the Center for Medicaid and CHIP Services Dan Brillman said in a statement. “If the state can use data to show that someone is working or qualifies for an exclusion, that person should not have to track down paperwork to prove it. And when someone needs support, they should know exactly what to do, when to do it, and where to go.”
“That’s how we build a Medicaid program that works better for people, connects them to work, education, and training opportunities, and supports paths to prosperity.”
Eliminating penalties while the kinks are worked out was something state governments asked for in the most recent lawsuit they filed against CMS less than two weeks ago. It’s unclear if that case will be dismissed now, given that the agency has acquiesced to the request.
However, another contention plaintiffs make in the filing is that the work requirements themselves are unconstitutional, as Medicaid falls under the purview of the states and the new federal oversight fundamentally changes the nature of the program.
Medicaid requirements were passed into law by the U.S. Congress in summer 2025 as part of a massive budget reconciliation package, dubbed the One Big Beautiful Bill Act.
Concerns remain over 'medically frail'
Another key sticking point has been exemptions put in place by Congress that would allow patients to avoid the work and schooling requirements while keeping their Medicaid insurance, in particular a provision that guarantees coverage to the “medically frail.”
CMS defines the term to mean when any “physical, mental, or other behavioral health condition significantly impairs the individual’s ability to comply with the community engagement requirement.”
That definition has been struck down by a U.S. District Court of Massachusetts, with Judge Richard Stearns issuing an injunction until a lawful definition is in place.
“Because enforcement of an unlawful definition of 'medically frail' may lead to the disenrollment of otherwise eligible vulnerable individuals relying on Medicaid coverage for continuity of care, the states—and public—face potential for great hardship in the absence of an injunction," he wrote.
For now, CMS has not changed the way it defines the exemption, and it’s unclear if the enforcement delay will also be used to develop a definition of medically frail that states believe they can apply accurately and fairly.
